South Africa
Coalition delays leave SA municipalities unable to govern
Politics & Governance

Coalition delays leave SA municipalities unable to govern

Municipal councils idle as ANC and DA haggle over who runs local services

Weeks after the local government elections, South Africa’s municipalities still have no coalition agreements in place. Councils cannot begin operating until functioning municipal governments are formed, and the delay is turning local bargaining into a national test of whether the governing arrangement can deliver stable administration.

Sandile Mnguni, speaking to 702’s John Perlman on Monday, warned that disagreements between the African National Congress (ANC) and the Democratic Alliance (DA) over the formation and leadership of local coalitions could eventually undermine the stability of the Government of National Unity (GNU) in the long term.

The arithmetic is straightforward. In some municipalities the ANC needs the DA to secure a governing majority. In others the DA needs the ANC. Both parties could also strike deals with smaller parties or independent councillors, and Mnguni noted reports of discussions between the DA and the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) party in some municipalities, despite the political distance between the two.

“Things are very fluid. They are still open to a number of changes,” he said, adding that it was difficult to predict where negotiations would lead, with different political configurations emerging across the country.

The sticking point, in his view, is who will run the municipalities day to day. “If it happens that they don’t find each other in relation to agreeing on the running of the municipalities, or even if they do find agreement in terms of working in the municipalities, some of the questions may be around who is going to be leading some of these positions, such as the mayor,” he said. Such disagreements could expose the GNU to instability, although successful negotiations could temporarily ease tensions.

He cautioned against assuming the national arrangement was immediately under threat. The stakes, though, reach past local government. “I do see some of these conversations in the long term having an impact in relation to the stability and the continuation of the current arrangement with the Government of National Unity between the ANC and the Democratic Alliance,” he said.

Meanwhile, resistance inside the ANC itself is shaping the negotiating environment. Mnguni said some ANC members were reluctant to enter coalitions with the DA, partly because of the party’s declining electoral support and unhappiness among some of its supporters with the existing GNU arrangement. He also pointed to the 2029 elections as an important consideration, saying parties were increasingly weighing their short-term electoral interests, and warned that agreements reached now might not hold, with disagreements potentially surfacing in the years ahead.

Beneath the coalition arithmetic sits a more basic question: is government actually performing? Asked whether the ANC’s relationship with the DA had contributed to voters abandoning the governing party, Mnguni said dissatisfaction was driven by several factors, with service delivery and national issues weighing heaviest, especially among a new generation of voters less motivated by historical and ideological loyalties.

“I think it’s a cocktail of everything,” he said. “But what has been more impactful in relation to the behaviour or how the electorate has been voting is more of the issues of national interest and especially issues around service delivery.”

Water shortages and the government’s response to corruption were among the issues he cited as influencing voter behaviour. Historical and ideological attachments still matter for some voters, but those loyalties are increasingly competing with practical concerns about how government performs.

For now, Mnguni said it was too early to draw firm conclusions about the direction of the ANC-DA relationship, given how sharply political dynamics differ from one municipality to the next. Whether the deals now being struck produce councils capable of delivering water, services and functioning administration, or whether leadership disputes stall them, is the question that will shape both municipal governance and, by his account, the stability of South Africa’s national government in the years ahead.

Q&A

Why can South African municipalities not begin operating after the elections?

Weeks after the local government elections, no coalition agreements are in place, and councils cannot begin operating until functioning municipal governments are formed.

What is the main sticking point in coalition negotiations?

Disagreements over the formation and leadership of local coalitions, especially who will run municipalities day to day and hold positions such as mayor, are the main sticking point.

How could local coalition disputes affect the Government of National Unity?

He warned that unresolved disagreements over running municipalities could in the long term undermine the stability and continuation of the Government of National Unity, though it is not immediately under threat.

What factors are driving voters away from the ANC according to Mnguni?

Service delivery and national issues weigh heaviest, especially water shortages and the government's response to corruption, particularly among a new generation of voters less motivated by historical and ideological loyalties.